Search:
search button
Where can consultancy take you?
 
7 posts
26.09.5
Tony/recruitgal etc pls advise
 
6 posts
23.09.5
Project Management
 
1 posts
22.09.5
RIp-Off
 
21 posts
29.12.6
Which is the best recruitment consultant ?
 
8 posts
22.09.5
Steps to international consultancy recruitment
 
1 posts
21.09.5
how do the levels of the big firms map to each other?
 
6 posts
23.09.5
Outsourcing vs consulting
 
1 posts
21.09.5
Summer Internships
 
1 posts
21.09.5
MBA....waste of time?
 
3 posts
21.09.5
Senior consultant advice required!!!
 
7 posts
20.09.5
Why are we never satisfied with our Salary?
 
4 posts
20.09.5
BAIN vs BCG- HELP!!!
 
4 posts
22.09.5
From NYC to London
 
19 posts
03.10.5
where to next?
 
1 posts
20.09.5
Tony-please can you advise
 
13 posts
22.09.5
Is it worth doing an MSc in Management Consultancy?
 
6 posts
22.09.5
Navigant Consulting?
 
3 posts
11.09.9
Change from actuary to consulting???!!
 
1 posts
19.09.5
consultant joke
 
6 posts
26.09.5
Capgemini's CDC vs IBM BCS
 
3 posts
29.09.5
Wannabee a Consultant
 
3 posts
20.09.5
Infosys recruiting in the UK ?
 
1 posts
18.09.5
New book "Rip Off" about consulting
 
5 posts
22.09.5
Interesting
 
1 posts
18.09.5
Consultancy or Accountancy
 
11 posts
20.10.5
Applying Overseas
 
1 posts
17.09.5
Mercer Management Consulting?
 
4 posts
18.09.5
Firm to watch out for in the coming years
 
6 posts
22.09.5
help anybody
 
1 posts
16.09.5
IB to Strat Consulting - advice sought
 
11 posts
18.09.5
Average MBA graduates salary
 
11 posts
21.09.5
CIMA - is it worth it???
 
5 posts
21.09.5
BCG- Deconstruction practice
 
1 posts
16.09.5
Lancaster and MA in Management Learning and Leadership
 
1 posts
15.09.5
To Tony Restell- Roland Berger
 
2 posts
16.09.5
HR consultancy
 
2 posts
16.09.5
What is strategy consulting really?
 
1 posts
14.09.5
Move into VC
 
1 posts
14.09.5
Question for RecruitGal
 
1 posts
14.09.5
researcher
 
1 posts
14.09.5
Open University Business School
 
10 posts
13.09.5
Is internal HR/OD on its way out?
 
5 posts
14.09.5
strategy at grad level - much difference btw firms?
 
4 posts
15.09.5
Systems integration or strategy
 
4 posts
15.09.5
MBA
 
2 posts
12.09.5
Accenture Strategy To What?
 
4 posts
14.09.5
Commercial Advantage Consulting
 
3 posts
12.09.5
CapGemini CDC for grads
 
7 posts
20.09.5
Top Companies
 
6 posts
09.09.5
 

BAIN vs BCG- HELP!!!

 
forum comment
#0 BAIN vs BCG- HELP!!!
 
John
20.09.5 00:00
 
I am interviewing both with Bain and BCG, but, until now, cannot make a decision on which one is better. What is the opinion of you guys out there??? Please help...! Cheers
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 Re: BAIN vs BCG- HELP!!!
 
Strat
20.09.5 00:00
 
Personally, unless you are looking to join at a fairly senior level, I'd base it on the people you meet and how well you think you'll get on with them and 'fit'. There are well-flagged differences in approach between the two firms, but when you consider than Bain left BCG in the early 70s, much of it will be folkloric by now. You'll get more of a feel for which one is 'better' for you from the people than from any abstract analysis of their reputations, approach, etc. Ultimately, they're both great firms if you know what you're getting yourself into and are comfortable with it. Best of luck.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 Re: Re: BAIN vs BCG- HELP!!!
 
John
20.09.5 00:00
 
Hi Strat. Can you please explain what do you mean by: "...if you know what you're getting yourself into "? Also, what is the difference in the approach between the two? Cheers
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 Re: Re: Re: BAIN vs BCG- HELP!!!
 
Strat
22.09.5 00:00
 
Only that it's going to be 'body and soul' hard work at any of the strat houses - it's just the nature of the job; it's intense. Fascinating, challenging, and rewarding, yes - but also intense. As to differences, you might find people articulating a view that BCG is more cerebral/conceptual/academic and Bain more data-driven/analytical/action-orientated, but these distinctions are very old: ADL begat BCG in the 60s, which begat Bain in the 70s, which begat LEK in the 80s and Parthenon in the 90s :) - it's inevitable that people try to talk up the differences when, objectively, the similarities might be the more striking. I'd still recommend choosing on the basis of the people, as you'll be spending an awful lot of time with them, but you could also look to understand the mix of work (sectors, type of engagement, length of project and working location) at the offices you might be joining.
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0